Shygirl has been releasing music in London for more than a decade, from her debut single, Want More, to Nymph, the 2022 debut album she made in a club-oriented style. SWALLOW!, out now, is her second album, co-produced with Karma Kid, and it reaches back past the club to the indie records of her childhood, The Cardigans among them. She has said that before she made it she had fallen into a happy relationship, and I find it hard to read the tracklist any other way. The titles could come from a prayer book left open on a bedside table: Lucky[Hymn], Mantra, Altar, Eternal.

A litany is one of the oldest ways people found to say something too large for a single voice. One voice calls, another answers, and the answer comes back again and again until the repetition carries the feeling by itself. I kept thinking of that form all through SWALLOW!, because Shygirl builds so many of these songs as a conversation with herself. On Lucky[Hymn] a bright, airy lead sings “So lucky to be seen by you” over glossy arpeggios and a clattering drum machine, and a breathier, lower voice answers from the side, calling it fate and asking how it tastes. On Submit the clear lead gives the whole confession in one line, “We can resist, only to submit”, while a flatter voice tucked into the mix murmurs the details underneath. The upper voice prays; the lower one is already in the room with you. I love that split. It gives devotion a body.

What makes the conversation work is where she stages it. Alyse is hard techno, pounding overdriven kicks and buzzing industrial stabs, and her voice floats above it in so much reverb that the noise never seems to touch her as she sings of the air she breathes and the sky she shares. Déjà Vu crawls at trip-hop pace over a rubbery bassline, her low, spoken cadence shadowed by a pitch-shifted double from somewhere far beneath, and when the two of them say “We were made for each other” the line carries a dark weight I like a great deal: a vow with something underground listening in. Real sets a restless UK garage pulse under soft, doubled vocals about a confusion that settles only when the other person is near. Song after song, the record keeps the body in a hurry and the voice at rest.

Mantra is the album’s brightest moment for me. Fast breakbeat drums and a deep sub-bass push a chant of rising, and a second, breathless voice keeps urging it higher. It is the litany at its purest, a word repeated until it becomes a direction, and it is the song I have gone back to most.

Altar is the darkest, and nearly as good: a heavy, slow beat under massive distorted synths, the voice floating through reverb and delay like someone answering a summons, asking to be told what to do. Of all the devotional titles, this is the one where the surrender sounds most like a ritual, and the haze of the production does the work of incense.

Then the record changes its clothes. Luvli is shoegaze, a wall of fuzz-drenched guitars and live drums, with her voice reduced to wordless sighs that melt into the haze. Sublime goes further, into crunchy indie rock with a bright lead guitar stepping forward and a slightly nasal drawl about trying the lonely way. This is where the childhood records come through, and where I am least convinced. Luvli works because the sighs keep her inside the same reverb world as the club songs. On Sublime she sits inside a band, and for the first time on the album she sounds like a guest at someone else’s song.

The doubt I miss elsewhere arrives on Live The Life You Like. Over a gritty breakbeat and abrasive, horn-like synths, a dry, deadpan voice sits close to the ear and asks whether the life you live is the life you like, and answers that it’s not enough. It is the one place where the devotion turns back on the singer, and I wish there were more of it. A little self-interrogation makes the surrender everywhere else sound chosen.

Eternal, the last song, sets a breathy, high voice over liquid drum and bass and layers it into call and response one more time, wanting to hold someone tighter while admitting that what remains is “Just a memory of a life”. The drums hurry and the voice lingers, and that is SWALLOW! in a single song: the body rushing towards someone, the mind already keeping the memory. Nymph proved that Shygirl could command a club. Here she lets someone else in, and for most of the album the voice that answers is as good as the voice that calls.